Casting
Sam Bottoms
Father Michael McCarren
Renée Coleman
September Lane
Edward Binns
Monsignor Frank Barrett
Dick Cavett
Himself
Page Hannah
Annie
Don Harvey
Nathan
Robert Lansing
C.A. Thomas
Holt McCallany
Jay
John Perkins
Cardinal Gurney
Carol Surface
Swim Coach
Tom Nowicki
Basketball Player #1
Robert Jayne
Basketball Player #3 (as Robert Jacoby)